The end of life is part of life that we must experience. Let us make the experience
a positive
one.
|
|
|
.
Dear
Loretta,
I just read your piece entitled "In Transition" from the May-June issue
of Yoga Journal.
It was so beautiful and moving that I had to let you know how much I
appreciated reading it. My mother lives in an assisted living residence
and is struggling mentally and physically. It was very comforting to
read about someone who had come to terms with her physical limitations,
was able to have joy in her life, and have what I would call a "good
death."
I hope and pray my mom can get to that place before she leaves us.
Thank you again for sharing your experience so eloquently.
Sincerely,
Lucy Tarabour |
- Facing Death
- PUBLISHED IN Yoga Chicago Magazine:
May June 2004.
- The Presbyterian Intercommunity
Hospital Newsletter, Spring 2005
- Mom and me
- Mom Flunked out of
Hospice...again!
- In Transition

- Facing Death
by
Loretta S. Downs
PRINTED IN YOGA CHICAGO MAGAZINE, MAY 2004
People I love die. My pets die. My rose bushes
die. People I do not know personally but to whom I feel an
attachment, die. I will die. In light of all this, I have
decided to make death a good experience, a practice in my life.
In the 1980s my circle of friends was heavily populated by gay
men who accepted me by wrapping me up in their intelligence,
creativity, courage, and colorful lifestyle. They showed my sad
spirit how to dance. They opened an artistic world I’d never
known and in which I felt at home. When my friends began to die
of AIDS, from California to New York, I found myself frozen by
feelings of inadequacy. There was nothing I could do to stop the
loss of people I cared about. It was difficult to be with them
when they were sick because I was helpless to stop the stampede
of ugly symptoms that would trample
them to death. They mirrored my own fragile mortality, which
induced more fear in me. In 1987, though not yet 40 years old, I
attended 14 funerals of men younger than I. My burden of grief
was like an iceberg, the tip visible and intimidating, but the
more dangerous part concealed beneath the surface of my stoic
facade. My heart knew there would be many more deaths yet to
come.
Sending cheery cards and making cheery phone calls once in
awhile were easy enough to do, but with each inadequate assist
to a friend, I felt a failure at friendship. As people I loved
were writing the last chapter in the book of their lives, I was
no more visible than a comma in the middle of one sentence. John
Welshons writes in his healing book, Awakening from Grief, “…a
large part of our grief is the sense of lost opportunity, and
that most of the lost opportunities occurred while we were with
our now-missing loved one.”
My response to my pain of not doing enough to help my friends,
of not being there for them, was to work harder and longer, make
more money and spend more; to drink and eat and smoke more, to
never say, “No, I can’t do that,” to run as fast as I could, and
to attach myself romantically to unavailable men because I would
not have to grieve their eventual departures.
After my father died in 1991, with all of us in denial that he
was dying, I went into therapy to deal with my food and
cigarette addiction, a cover-up for the real issues. A year
later, beginning to face my avoidance of emotional pain, I
stopped drinking. Then I stopped smoking. Exercise slowly became
a routine. I got food under control. My relationships changed
from giving to receiving. Men became available for me. Work got
balanced with play and rest. In her autobiographical exploration
of grief, In Lieu of Flowers, Nancy Cobb writes, “Coming out of
a depression, I suppose, is a bit like coming back from the
dead. It’s learning to breathe again. And it is certainly as
humbling to rediscover the most basic of life’s pleasures as it
is to lose them.” The Universe slowly and gently led me forward,
presenting opportunities to make new choices.
In 1995 I consciously decided that I wanted to know more about
caring for the sick and dying. I wanted to be emotionally
prepared to be available for my friends when they needed me
most. To learn the lessons I sought, I became a volunteer on the
19-bed AIDS unit at Illinois Masonic Hospital where I had
visited too many of my friends over the years. At the hospital I
was able to observe hundreds of patients dealing with the
symptoms of a life-threatening illness. Some were living the end
of their lives. Some had family support, some had been
abandoned. A striking difference between the experience of
patients or families who denied and fought the reality of death
and those who accepted it soon became apparent to me.
The people in denial carried a palpable burden of emotional pain
and suffering and families often expressed this in the presence
of the people they loved, who lay dying. I witnessed angry
patients and families abusing the compassionate staff. I
witnessed inconsolable grief, hearts hitting icebergs they
pretended they did not see. I witnessed patients demanding
extreme medical treatments. I witnessed strenuous passings that
sometimes went on for days. I witnessed an unwillingness to
understand the obvious: death comes to every living thing.
There were others who, by accepting the reality of what is, were
unburdened of the fear of dying. These patients and families
sought to live every day fully, with love, friendship, kindness
and gratitude. Those in acceptance seemed to act as though each
minute could be a positive, meaningful experience. Everyone
around them was drawn in to their light. They had more visitors
who came bearing gifts of favorite foods, clothes, magazines and
always stories. The staff stayed with them longer. These seemed
to have less extreme symptoms. Death arrived more peacefully for
the accepting. Their loved ones carried sadness but not the
bitter pain I saw too often in the death-denying survivors.
The evidence made me want to connect more closely with those
dying in acceptance, so I joined Hospice Partners as a volunteer
patient companion. Hospice is a philosophy of support and
comfort care that envelops a person who has accepted his or her
dying, along with family and friends, in a blanket of hope. It
is a safe haven where a team of specialists form a cocoon around
the dying one and guide him or her through physical
transformation while encouraging spiritual healing along the
way. My role as a volunteer is to listen to the feelings and
thoughts of those I encounter living the end of their lives. I
am to be present in silence as well as in laughter and tears. I
am to encourage all the appropriate activity and behavior my
patients are able to perform while I create a space for them to
engage in spiritual healing. I am to support the caregivers, to
lighten their load. I am to be open to building a friendship
that will soon end. And some that will never end. I am to be
open to learn how to die myself. The practice continues. Now my
patients and their families are my teachers.
In his experiential book, A Year to Live, Steven Levine writes,
“Preparing for death is one of the most profoundly healing acts
of a lifetime.” Two years ago, two young women were killed in a
freak accident when a scaffolding fell from the Hancock Center
onto their car. Reading the story I received a jolt like
lighting hit me: that could happen to me. Despite my growing
awareness of death as a part of life, the concept that it could
take me without warning was new knowledge to process. “What if I
were to die this year,” I wondered? “Am I as prepared as I could
be?” The answer was a resounding, “No.”
Two issues presented themselves immediately. Am I doing the work
of healing my soul and do I have my legal business in order?
Another loud, “No!” Since I am unmarried and my only living
parent is 91, legally my sister would be in charge of my life
should I become unable to speak for myself. She loves me dearly,
but she would prefer not to have that responsibility. The first
thing I needed to do was appoint a Health Care Power of Attorney
and write out a Living Will so that my Power of Attorney, my
doctor and my sister would know what my medical directives for
care would be in case I could not speak for myself. This
exercise was easy as I had thought about it often, and there is
abundant information available to execute an intelligent,
meaningful and legal document.
Next, I needed to update my five-year old will. This was not so
easy when I viewed my will as an opportunity to make a
difference in the lives of many instead of merely a few. Some of
my values, relationships and assets had changed since I wrote my
previous will. It took nearly nine months of thinking and making
lists to come up with a satisfying distribution of my major
assets and my most important objects. As for the smaller objects
in my life, I’m going to follow “Pauline’s Plan.” When you visit
her home and admire something she owns, she puts a sticker with
your name on it. I learned this when I commented on a painting.
“Oh, no, Pauline, you don’t need to put my name on it,” I
politely pleaded, embarrassed. She lifted the piece off the wall
and discovered someone’s name already on it. Mortified, I
stammered, “Oh, don’t--don’t worry, that’s OK.” “Don’t you
worry, Darling,” she said softly, peeling a fresh sticker,
“We’re not speaking anymore.”
The last legal issue I covered was writing out my burial wishes
and asking my nephew if he would execute them. My delivery of
this request was poorly timed. A week after I had hurriedly
explained my wishes, he called me somewhat tentatively and
asked, “Aunt Lu? Are you sick?” “No, Honey, I’m not sick,” I
said with a little shame for causing him unnecessary grief. It
was not easy to get a laugh out of him but we did grow closer at
that moment.
Finishing my legal business lifted a burden of responsibility
from my shoulders because should I become unable to represent
myself or unexpectedly die my decision makers know my wishes. My
assets will be distributed to the people and places I want to
honor in this way. I am free of these worries--and I can always
change the stickers.
Now what was I to do about healing my soul? For years I had been
facing my grief over the deaths of people I love by processing
it and expressing it in healthy ways like crying and talking
about my feelings. I know death is a part of life, but what of
all those personal and potential losses that I might have to
face one day? What was I doing about my fear of not having
enough money? My fear of growing older? My conflicted emotions
about my frail elderly mother? My fear of pain? My fear of a
lost mind? My fear of being alone? My fear of death? Where would
I learn to reach peace about my death? There was no question
that it was time to face my fears, embrace them and forgive
myself for holding them at all.
As soon as I opened myself up, The Universe led me to more
teachers. Mediation tapes and brochures for mediation courses
found their way into my hands. Mitch Albom signed my old, worn
copy of his essential book, Tuesdays with Morrie. I received a
gift of Wayne Dyer’s Ten Secrets for Success and Inner Peace.
Buddhist thoughts kept showing up in my email. My body worker
called to remind me to return for another session. A Yoga
Chicago magazine came into my home suggesting it was time to
renew my attendance at yoga class. My trust in God expanded. My
hospice experiences were all positive. Opportunities to make
changes were popping up all around me like tulips in April.
The journey to acceptance of my own tender mortality continues,
but the path is smoother, more direct. Now, when I think of
growing older, I see myself as a beautiful wise woman whose
knowing will help others to reach peace. When I think of losing
my mother, I try to appreciate her in the moment. When I say
“Goodbye” to her, I mean it. When I think of having pain I
accept it and trust that my caregivers will do all they can to
provide me with comfort. When I consider that I could one day
lose my mind, I tell myself that my value will be as a teacher
for someone. When I think of being alone, I watch lovers and
take the affection I witness between them into myself, feeling
gratitude that I am able to see people expressing love to each
other. I borrow some of their love and make it my own. When I
think of dying, I think of how beautiful life is. I think of how
fortunate I am to learn these lessons. I feel gratitude for the
privilege of being with the dying. I feel love all around me. I
feel The Universe expanding around me in hope.
Then I think that if I had to die today, this would be a good
day to die, because I am at peace.
Top
- Mom and me
By Loretta Downs (Printed in Yoga Chicago Magazine March/April 2005) After three weeks on the Psychiatric Ward, my Mom is back at
the Fairmont Care Center chemically adjusted to her best
sweet-self appreciating her caregivers with a prayer chant,
"Thank you, thank you, thank you," any time they serve her.
She weighs only 101, prefers to eat just the soup and
dessert and call it a meal. She sleeps most of the time, in
the private room her old house pays for, facing a wall
covered in family pictures and great-grandchildren art that
she says, "is my life".
Last night I stopped in around eight o'clock. After taking
off my coat and leaning into her hollow cheek to deliver a
kiss and speak into her ear so she could hear me, I asked,
"What would you like me to do for you?" "Just be with me," she answered.
I zipped off my boots, then crawled in her bed to stretch
myself along her back and hold her, but she said, "No, you
should be over here," pointing to in front of her. I stepped
around the bed with red stocking feet and slid in next to
her. We made spoons. She wrapped her thin arms tightly
around me, and I wove mine into hers. She squeezed me
saying, "My little girl, my baby, my beautiful Loretta,"
squeezing and releasing while I bathed her pillow in healing
tears.
"How was your day, Mom?" "Oh, it was beautiful," she replied, with gratitude in her
voice. “They treat me like a baby.”
She wanted to know what I've been doing to keep busy, a
question she asks more often these days. I talked about
Indigo, the 8-month old daughter of my young friend Barb
whose own mother died when she was 22. I’m privileged to be
the baby’s Auntie Loretta and spend some hours each week
playing with her because she balances my life of being with
the dying. I told Mother that her latest achievement is
trying to crawl and promised to bring the baby for another
visit when the weather improves. We talked about family
members, my friends, and her girlfriends in the nursing
home. I decide not to tell her that while she was "away" her
brother Pete was diagnosed with colon cancer or that her
youngest sibling, at 86, had a stroke. Or that the father of
my childhood friend Lynn and two of the residents down the
hall from her room died in one week. I'll tell her all of
that another time. I will tell her so she can pray for them.
We stayed there for an hour, holding each other, creating
the kind of intimacy I spent my life yearning for. I was
visiting a mystical, foreign place I'd always dreamed
existed but never knew the route to reach it. She stroked my
head, remarking that, "You have Daddy's hair." Then, with
reverence, "I feel like I'm touching Daddy." I asked her
what it was like the day she met him and she told me with
girlish delight in her voice, "He kissed me and he said 'I
think I'm going to marry you!'" She paused a minute before
she said in a low, slow voice, "And I never let go of him."
I gave her time to live in her memories, before I asked,
reluctantly, "Are you tired, Mom?" "Yes, "she admitted softly. "I love you, Mommy," I said, failing not to let the words
deliver tears as punctuation. "Oh, I love you, Loretta, I love you," she said, not crying,
but squeezing me with all her might, kissing my head, "It's
so hard to say goodnight. I don’t want you to leave."
Her new doctor, with extraordinary lack of enlightenment,
would not assign her to hospice after discharging her from
the hospital last Monday. He told me, "She doesn't have
cancer or something like that." She, I, her care-giving
staff at The Fairmont, all need the extra care of a hospice
team. So many are deprived the specialized care of hospice
because, like the rest of us, doctors see death as failure.
I had some of the best moments of my entire life yesterday.
I have no recall of my mother ever holding me like she did
then. Perhaps she did and I forgot it in all the shame and
pain that came between us. Perhaps I never allowed her to
get that close. Perhaps she didn't know how to show me love.
Perhaps the learning couldn't come for either of us until
now, at the end of her life. It doesn't matter. Whatever
happened in the past no longer matters, because I will be
able to feel the moments that I had yesterday, feel the
safety of my mother's arms around me and hear her call me
beautiful until the day I die.
After years of being with people dying, I finally understand
why some take so long to leave this side of life despite the
ravages of disease or the accumulated, continuous losses
that come with very old age. It is because they will miss us
as much as we will miss them.
Top
- Mom
Flunked out of Hospice--Again!
My mother was weighed this week and has gained eight pounds
since June when she entered into the care of hospice at 110
pounds under a “failure to thrive” diagnosis. Gaining eight
pounds is not failing to thrive, so she will be discharged from
hospice next week, remaining at the Fairmont Nursing Home, the
place she calls home and the home in which she will die. While I celebrate the gift of more time with her, I am also very
sad that she will certainly grow more frail and dependent,
suffering more losses of capacity and ability. Already she has
difficulty eating without assistance, and at some point she will
not be able to feed herself at all.
The Director of Nursing at The Fairmont called me this morning
to say Mom had been up at 6 a.m., screaming that someone had
thrown water on her. She was sitting up, her bed was soaked,
she’d taken off her diaper and, of course, wet the sheets. They
wanted us to know in case she relates the incident to us or
continues to be angry with the staff. She is as often angry and
belligerent with her caregivers as she is appreciative and
thankful. I never know what sets her moving in either direction
and I’ve given up trying. My role is to just be with her, in
either mood, accepting her. Yesterday we had a sweet visit. I brought a ham and Swiss on
rye, cole slaw and her favorite coconut donut from the deli. She
thanked me for “the picnic.” I read her mail--a card from her
son and one from a thoughtful friend of mine. My cousin Andrea
showed up unexpectedly. She brought a copy of an interview she’d
done with Mom three years ago for a resident profile for the
Fairmont newsletter when Andrea had worked there as a social
worker. We drank coffee with ice cream in it and shared the
donut while Andrea read the profile.
Mom listened with her whole heart. Afterward I asked her if she
would like us to read it at her funeral--”When you die in seven
years when you’re 100!” She actually shed a tear (rare for her)
and said that was a wonderful idea. This was one of her few
admissions to eventually dying. I’m going there again tonight for dinner; my regular restaurant
is now The Fairmont. I will see if she remembers this morning’s
events--or yesterday’s. Keep us in your prayers, Loretta
Top
- In Transition
Anna Piazza Schenk September 17, 1912 – April 10, 2006
Mom left yesterday, as the early morning sun smiled outside
her window, with me at her side. I sat next to her with one
hand on the soft skin behind her cool neck and the other on
her rosary praying a Hail Mary when I realized she’d stopped
breathing. It was so peaceful I almost missed it.
On March 22nd my mother excitedly told me she was taking a
trip, “on a cloud, a big piece of cloud.” She would leave
when she had “everything set,” and “travel around the
world.” She would put rooms on the cloud, “fix that up with
furniture because we’re a big family and we’ll be getting a
lot of company, so we have to make it comfortable for them.”
I asked her if she would give me some time to pack. She
said, “Oh, yes. We’ve got to have our suitcases ready to
leave.”
We were in bed together. I leaned into her good ear and
asked, “Are you happy?” She replied clearly, for the first time I ever heard her say
it, “Yes, I am happy.” I deepened the question, “How do you know you’re happy?”
“Because I have ideas that make me happy. Like this trip I
want to take. It’ll take two or three months to make the
trip alone.” “And that makes you happy?” I asked, feeling happy for her. “Yes,” she said, smiling. “I’ve got plans and that makes you
think better.”
Ten days later my mother had a stroke that left her right
side paralyzed and unable to speak or swallow. My sister and
I decided not to hospitalize her, not to artificially
hydrate or feed her and instead we chose to allow her a
natural death supported by the compassionate care of
Heartland Hospice whose specialized staff would come to The
Fairmont Care Center where Mom lived.
The last week of her life was a gift for all of us who
participated in her dying. She had time to receive a great
amount of physical, spiritual and emotional attention given
with love. Her familiar hospice team embraced her with
devotional care once again.
I had time to process her loss while caring for her to the
best of my ability. I was able to sit in her bed, hold her
and tell her the long list of lessons that she’d taught me.
I was able to tell her how meaningful her life has been. I
was able to let her leave.
I was able to receive care for myself, from my friends—and
hers. Residents fed me candy and cookies from their private
stash. They held me and let me cry on their old bones. They
rolled into her room to touch her hand, to leave a prayer,
to let me know how much she was loved.
She was able to die in the place she’s called home for
nearly six years, in the elegant hospice room that resembles
a suite in a fancy hotel where her friends and family had
the space to be with her. She allowed me to witness the
miracle unfold, to be in her grace, to watch the butterfly
leave the chrysalis.
Moments after she died, my sister arrived, then Stephanie,
my friend since high school who loves my mom, then Margaret
her remarkable hospice aide, who was celebrating her
birthday. We bathed my mother like she was a queen. We
dressed her in her favorite fluffy pink robe, laid her head
on a big, soft, bright blue butterfly pillow. We sprinkled
her bed with rose petals and placed more in an empty candy
box set at the foot of her bed. We sent out word inviting
visitors and within minutes a procession of wheelchairs,
walkers and uniformed staff came to say goodbye.
They held us and we held them. There was joy under all the
tears. Everyone said, “She looks so peaceful, so beautiful.”
Each mourner was offered flower petals “as your final gift
to Anna,” and each of them placed their gift on her bed with
reverence.
We waited for Monday morning bingo to finish so her last of
the neighbors could say goodbye before we helped the funeral
director wrap her up with all her gifts, set her on a gurney
and cover her in green velvet. Six residents and staff
formed an honor guard and we all escorted her through the
corridors of The Fairmont and out the door, waving “Goodbye,
Anna,” as her body was placed in the van.
I am sitting with joy knowing that my mother died with
dignity, in peace, without pain, cared for by hands that
loved her, and in her own words, happy.
Top
|
|
Home | About | Speaker Info | Presentations | Chrysalis Room | Articles | Advice | Blog | Contact
The material on this web site is copyrighted. Please submit a written request
for permission to use photos or to quote the writing and we will happily grant
your wish.
This site was last updated
03/07/07
|